How the Type of Crash Shapes a Michigan Claim
Nationally, CPSC reports that overturns and collisions with another vehicle or with a stationary object, like a tree, were the most common hazards in off-highway vehicle deaths. Occupants were frequently ejected in those incidents. A rollover means the vehicle tips onto its side or roof. Michigan riders face the same kinds of events: rollovers on slopes, ejections, fires, crashes with other machines, and collisions at trail and road crossings.
Each event can point toward a different legal theory. These theories are separate, and one does not prove another:
- Recreational negligence asks whether another rider, a driver or an owner who let someone ride failed to use reasonable care, and whether that failure caused the injury.
- Premises or landowner liability asks what the person who owns or controls the land owed the rider.
- Product liability asks whether the vehicle or a part, such as a restraint, door, steering or brake component, was defective and whether that defect caused the injury.
A rollover or crash alone does not show a defect, or that anyone was careless. A detailed guide to UTV rollover claims covers that distinction further.
Michigan's recreational-use statute matters for land claims. Section 324.73301 of the Michigan Compiled Laws applies to a person on another's land who has not paid the owner, tenant or lessee "a valuable consideration." It covers uses such as "motorcycling, snowmobiling, or any other outdoor recreational use or trail use, with or without permission." For that person, the statute provides that no cause of action arises against the owner, tenant or lessee "unless the injuries were caused by the gross negligence or willful and wanton misconduct" of that person. A similar rule covers Michigan trailways and other public trails.
If you were riding on someone else's land without paying, this rule can narrow a claim against the landowner to gross negligence or willful and wanton misconduct. Whether it applies turns on the land, the activity and whether anything was paid, so details such as who owned the property and any fee or permit are worth noting.
Federal law adds one more layer, for ATVs only. Under 15 U.S.C. § 2089, new ATVs sold in the United States must meet a mandatory federal standard. That statute defines an ATV as a motorized off-highway vehicle "designed to travel on 3 or 4 wheels, having a seat designed to be straddled by the operator and handlebars for steering control." That definition does not reach a UTV or side-by-side. The site's page on the CPSC ATV safety standard explains it.